If you are descended from Daniel Doyle and Anne Carbery of County Westmeath (1800s),
please contact your cousins in Argentina and Australia by E-mail ...
mrdoyle@pac.com.au

The Order of St Patrick




The Badge is George V's Diamond Star. Made around 1890, The Star's centre has a shamrock of emeralds, with the Saint's cross in rubies on a diamond background. 'George, Prince of Wales, April 1910' is engraved on the reverse

The Order's motto was 'Quis Separabit MDCCLXXXIII' - 'Who will separate us 1783'.


The badge of the Usher of the Order


Order of St Patrick

The Order of St Patrick was founded in 1783, to reward those in high office in Ireland and Irish peers on whose support the government of the day depended. It therefore served as the national Order of Ireland as the Garter was for England and the Thistle for Scotland. The Order lapsed in 1974 with the death of the last surviving recipient, Prince Henry, Duke of Gloucester.

Originally, the number of Knights of St Patrick was 15, and this increased to 22 in 1833. The Knights wore mantles of sky-blue satin, and the star of the Order was embroidered in silver on the right breast.

The Order's most famous insignia were the badge and star used by the Lords Lieutenant; these were made available for the serving Lord Lieutenant's use in 1830 by William IV. The insignia were made from 394 stones taken in part from some of Queen Charlotte's jewellery and from one of the Order of the Bath Badges which had belonged to her husband George III. Known as the 'Irish Crown Jewels', the insignia were stolen from Dublin Castle in 1907 and never recovered.

The Order effectively went into abeyance with the establishment of the Irish Free State in 1922.

 

Order of St Patrick - George IV's Sovereign's Sash Badge (on left), made in 1812. In the centre is a green enamelled shamrock, each leaf with a diamond five-arched crown, set on a red enamelled cross of St Patrick. The Badge has a swivel suspension loop of eight diamonds, and the reverse has the same design in coloured enamel and gold. 

   


WHO PINCHED THE IRISH CROWN JEWELS?

Every nation has its treasures, but the Irish Crown Jewels met a mysterious fate.

by Michael Nash

Almost every nation has its State treasures. They may be symbols of national pride, such as Crown Jewels, or documents that encapsulate national history, as with the American Declaration of Independence. Some of these treasures now reside in museums. Others, most especially crowns and other royal regalia, are regularly worn by heads of State. The regalia variously referred to as the Irish Crown Jewels or the State Jewels of Ireland, however, met a more unusual and mysterious fate.

Properly called the jewels belonging to the Most Illustrious Order of Saint Patrick, they were created to be presented to the National Order of Chivalry of Ireland, the Order of Saint Patrick, for use by the Viceroy or visiting Sovereigns. In 1830 the Crown Jewellers, Rundell & Bridge, created the regalia from jewels that had belonged to Queen Charlotte, the consort of George III. These diamonds, rubies, and other stones possibly included the rose diamond given to the Queen by the Sultan of Turkey and the jewels she received from Mogul Emperor Shah Alam.

The Honours of St. Patrick consisted of two principal pieces--the star and the badge. The eight-pointed star consisted mostly of Brazilian diamonds. In the centre, a shamrock (or trefoil) of emeralds shone from the heart of a ruby cross which lay upon a background of blue enamel. Encircling this central motif was the motto of the order, Quis Separabit? (who can separate us?) and the date MDCCLXXIII (1783) all in rose diamonds.

The badge was of similar splendour, with its trefoil of emeralds on a ruby cross surrounded by a blue enamel band bearing the motto and date in rose diamonds, which was itself enclosed in an outer circle of large Brazilian diamonds, the whole being surrounded by a harp and loop framed in diamonds.

These creations joined some more traditional Irish regalia--two silver maces and the Irish Sword of State--which were carried before the Viceroy on State occasions. All of these, with separate individual collars and badges of members of the Order, were kept in the strongroom of Dublin Castle under the custody of the Ulster King of Arms, the Principal Herald of Ireland, and his assistants.

British monarchs did not travel all that frequently to Ireland. After King John, Richard II took an interest in the Emerald Isle, visiting it twice. Then, apart from the battles of the great rivals, uncle and nephew James II and William III, the next State Visit was that of George IV in 1821. The first monarch to avail herself of the jewels created by Rundell & Bridge was Queen Victoria, who came with Prince Albert in 1849 and 1861. Thereafter, nearly 40 years passed before the next royal visit--again by Victoria in 1900.

The jewels were also used on the occasion of the investiture of the Prince of Wales, later to become Edward VII, in the Order of St. Patrick in 1868. The very next year the Church of Ireland was established, and the religious ceremonies associated with such investitures were thereafter curtailed. In 1903 King Edward and Queen Alexandra made a formal visit to Ireland, during which the jewels were used, and they returned again informally in April 1904. During the 1903 visit the Ulster King of Arms, Sir Arthur Vicars, was invested a Knight Commander of the Royal Victorian Order. He remained Ulster King of Arms (the principal Herald in Ireland) from 1893 until 1908.

The routine, if relatively infrequent, appearances of the Honours of St. Patrick came to an abrupt end, however, in 1907, during a visit by King Edward and Queen Alexandra. Prior to their arrival, for the purpose of investing Lord Castletown with the Order of St. Patrick, it was discovered that the jewels had been stolen. The King became apoplectic with rage when he found out that not only had they been stolen, but they had apparently been missing for at least a month.

The jewels themselves were estimated to be worth about £40,000 in 1907, but of course their symbolic value was much greater. The public amazement over the theft was nothing compared with the official consternation. Nothing quite like it had happened since Colonel Blood made off with the English Crown Jewels from the Tower of London in 1671. From the very beginning, the Vice-Regal Commission which investigated the theft suspected that that it was an inside job, because both the Irish police force and the detective staff had their headquarters in Dublin Castle. Arthur Vicars, who denied all complicity, was made the official scapegoat, and was compelled to resign in 1908.

The report stated that those concerned had showed "a strange want of a sense of responsibility and in fact deliberate carelessness not only for failing to ensure that the priceless crown jewels were kept in a suitably fitted strong room, but also because after the jewels had disappeared there was a strange delay in reporting their circumstances." The use of the word "strange" in the report hardly seems adequate to describe the unusual circumstances surrounding the whole affair. Not only did it appear that the theft had been an inside job, but also that there was almost certainly an official cover-up regarding the real culprit and the fate of the jewels. State jewels had been stolen before, only to be recovered, so for some time there was hope, even expectation, that the Irish Crown Jewels would reappear and the thieves be identified. But this never happened, at least not formally. The unsolved mystery coloured the King's personal attitude to Ireland for the brief remainder of his reign. Finally, he abandoned the investigation, disgusted, it is said, with the inept detective system of Dublin.

Philip Magnus, writing about the theft in 1964, noted that King Edward, though he remained profoundly dissatisfied, was also thankful that worse scandal had been avoided. What was this "worse scandal"? Did King Edward actually know the identity of the thief? There seems no doubt that the Official Report was tampered with, for it contains significant omissions.

Rumours persisted that the thief was a highly placed person. Vicars' three assistants, all of whom resigned, were: Pierce Mahony (the son of Vicars' half-brother and therefore his own nephew) whom he had made Cork Herald; Francis Bennett-Goldney, and Francis or Frank Shackleton.

The last of these seems the most likely culprit. Brother of the famed Antarctic explorer Sir Ernest Shackleton, Frank Shackleton was a charismatic personality who lived by his wits and his charm, ingratiating himself into the highest social circles. But his real friends were not of the type "to inspire confidence among the police or the public." Frank Shackleton was a practising homosexual at a time when such behaviour almost frequently led to secrecy and blackmail. (There is strong circumstantial evidence that all four of the heralds indulged in "scandalous stag-parties.") The consequent nervousness in royal circles was understandable--one of the associates and confidantes of Frank Shackleton was none other than the Duke of Argyll, who was the King's own brother-in-law. Shackleton was also in severe financial difficulties.

While attending a luncheon party on 4th July, 1907, Shackleton remarked that he would not be at all surprised to learn that the Irish Crown Jewels would one day be stolen. Two days later, the theft was discovered.

Each of the heralds ultimately met with unpleasant, and, in most cases, highly suspicious ends. Pierce Mahony died in 1914, victim of what has been described as "a very peculiar shooting accident." Francis Bennett-Goldney died as the result of a motor accident in 1918. Sir Arthur Vicars was assassinated in 1921.

The prime suspect, Frank Shackleton, met with a less dramatic, although no less disagreeable, fate. Just two days after the death of King Edward in 1910, Shackleton came to financial grief when one of the companies in which he was involved failed. Three years later, he was declared bankrupt and was imprisoned for fraud. After his release he lived under a pseudonym and died in obscurity in the inter-war years, exactly when and where, like the rest of his life, being shrouded in uncertainty.

No trace has ever been found of the Grand Master's Diamond Star and Badge, the fine gold collars, or the Mahoney family diamonds which Vicars also had in his custody. In 1976, a file of the Irish government that was opened to the public for the first time contained the following intriguing memorandum, dated 1927:

'The President would not like them [the jewels] to be used as a means of reviving the Order [of St. Patrick] or to pass into any hands other than those of the State . . . He understands that the Castle Jewels are for sale and that they could be got for £2,000 or £3,000. He would be prepared to recommend their purchase for the same reason.'

The memorandum is signed by the Assistant Secretary of the Executive Council, Michael McDunphy, and the President referred to is William Cosgrave, President of the Executive Council and Prime Minister of the Irish State from 1922 to 1932.

This revelation opens up the tantalizing prospect that the Irish Crown Jewels were still in existence in 1927 and may still exist today. Stories abound that the jewels have found their way into private collections in the United States--not unlikely in the light of transatlantic traffic in such objects, both legal and illegal.

Some have also suggested that the Irish Republican Brotherhood, the forerunners of the IRA, engineered the robbery as a political embarrassment to the English. But this is purely speculation, and it seems unlikely that, having successfully pulled off such a coup, the Brotherhood would have kept it a secret.

On 10th July, 1982, the Irish Times ran an article titled "The Theft of the Irish Crown Jewels," which added some interesting facts and speculation to the debate. The article mentions that Lord Haddo, the son of the Viceroy, Lord Aberdeen, was a frequent visitor to the Castle, and quite possibly took part in the heralds' "nightly orgies." He allegedly "stole" the jewels on a previous occasion as a practical joke against the easily intoxicated Vicars, although he later returned them. The incident, apparently, did nothing to persuade Vicars of the need for better security.

The Irish Times article says that after the theft, Shackleton and an accomplice, Captain Richard Gorges, with whom he had served in the army in South Africa, may have sold the jewels to a Dutch pawnbroker for £5,000. It is also possible that, given their association with people close to the throne, Shackleton and Gorges were allowed to enjoy the benefits of their crime as the price of their silence.

Interest in the theft continued. On 29th September, 1983, the Irish Times announced that the hunt for the jewels was being renewed. The report claimed that Irish detectives had been tipped off about the possible whereabouts of the regalia by a man who claimed that his family had been entrusted with this secret. A spokesman for the Garda Siochana, the Republican police force, said the man had provided detailed information and that his claims were being taken seriously. A huge search employing dogs and sophisticated metal detectors began in the foothills of the Dublin Mountains, some miles outside the city. Its precise location was kept secret, as was the identity of the informant. Unfortunately, nothing came of the effort.

Should the jewels ever be found again, questions of ownership would inevitably arise. Possible claims of the British Government may have to be set against those of the National Museum of Ireland, to say nothing of the Ulster Museum. Who is the legal successor to the Government of Ireland in 1907, when the jewels were stolen and Edward VII was sovereign?

In name, at least, successive English kings remained Head of State in Ireland until 1937. King George V was the last sovereign to visit Dublin in state, which he did with Queen Mary in 1911. Interestingly, he himself wanted to continue the quest for the stolen jewels, but he found that his father, Edward VII, had issued a royal directive to Lord Aberdeen that Vicars and his heralds were to be dismissed from their offices, and a lid be placed on the whole affair of the missing Crown Jewels to prevent further scandal. Edward had since passed from the scene, but the dictum he had imposed upon the Government in Ireland continued to ensure that the authorities officially ignored the case of the missing jewels.

     
Purging the Order of Saint Patrick

As a result of the theft of the Crown Jewels, King Edward VII's intended investiture of Lord Castletown into the Order of Saint Patrick during the visit of 1907 had to wait until February 1908, when Vicars had been "purged." The King had insisted on the Order's being re-constituted, which necessitated the removal of all existing officers--a subtle move. The vacant posts were then filled by Captain Nevile Wilkinson, a son-in-law of the Earl of Penbroke, who became Ulster Herald; Captain Guillamore O'Grady, who became Dublin Herald; and Mr. George Burtschaell, who became Athlone Pursuivant.

The new Ulster Herald was faced with a problem, for, apart from the remaining insignia of the Order of St. Patrick, the strong room in Dublin Castle contained the silver maces and the Irish Sword of State, which were carried before the Lord Lieutenant on ceremonial occasions, and all three were needed for a coming levee. Vicars refused to hand over the keys, but Wilkinson, undaunted, broke into the inner sanctuary with the aid of crowbars wielded by two lusty labourers supplied by the Board of Works. "Then," reported the new Ulster Herald, "my quest accomplished. I quietly joined the guests as they sat over their coffee, and pointed out the recovered symbols of state to His Excellency as we passed through the Throne Room on our way to join the ladies."

There could scarcely have been a greater contrast between this practical, honest soldier, as Ulster Herald, and his fussy and fastidious predecessor.

 

The First Irish Crown Jewel

The stolen jewels weren't the first Irish Crown Jewels. In 1154 the one and only Englishman to become Pope, Nicholas Breakspeare, was elected as Pope Adrian IV. The next year he presented Ireland to the English king, Henry II, as a papal fief or lordship, he himself remaining overlord. There was also a theory, probably spurious, that all islands belonged to the Pope.

John of Salisbury, one of the few reliable historians of the Middle Ages, wrote: "It was at my prayer that he [Adrian IV] have and conceded to the illustrious King of England, Henry II, Ireland, to be possessed by hereditary right; for by ancient right, according to the Donation of Constantine, all islands are said to belong to the Roman church. Through me, too, did the Pope transmit a golden ring, decked with a single emerald, with which the king's investiture was to be completed."

This then can be called the first Irish Crown Jewel. Unfortunately the investiture was never completed because Henry refused to accept the Pope's terms, one penny each year for every house in Ireland, and present papal rights to remain intact.

Henry II, however, appointed his son, Prince John, Lord of Ireland in 1185, and the Pope, by this time Pope Urban II, sent a gold crown adorned with peacock feathers for the coronation of John as Lord of Ireland. However, John offended the Irish chieftains by laughing at their long beards (it was the fashion then in England to be clean-shaven), and they not unnaturally took umbrage and defied the upstart prince. John was never crowned with this, the second Irish Crown Jewel. What happened to the emerald ring and peacock crown is not known.

The lordship of Ireland came to an end when Henry VIII broke with the Pope. In 1541 the Irish Parliament gave him the title "King of Ireland," which, he repudiated, only to proclaim himself King of Ireland on his own authority!

In 1782 Henry Gratan, an English minister intent on ameliorating the Irish situation, had the Irish Parliament declared independent of the English one, and the following year, 1783, George III, who in a 60-year reign never set foot outside England, created the Order of Saint Patrick.

It was for this order that the Irish jewels were created in 1830, to be worn by the Grand Master of the Order and by visiting sovereigns.

 

The Most Illustrious Order

The Order of Saint Patrick and its Knights

PETER GALLOWAY

 

The Order of Saint Patrick was instituted in 1783. This is the definitive history of the Order, setting it in context as a political, social, cultural and ceremonial constituent of viceregal Ireland. Also included: a survey of the 146 knights of the order appointed between 1783 and 1936, and complete lists of the Grand Masters, Knights and Officers

 .


20 colour illustrations
53 b/w illustrations
256 pages
Size: 29 x 21
ISBN: 0 90629 023 6
First published: 1999
U S dollar $90.00, Sterling £50.00

 

 Celt Knot

 

  Doyle
Home Page
Irish Kilts?
Irish Tartans?
 
Clan Gathering
2013
Certificate of
Irish Heritage
DubhGhaill / Doyle
DNA Surname Project
Irish Chiefly Succession
In The 21st Century
The Alliance
of the Ancient Clans
of the Kingdom of Desmond

Meaning of the
 Name

The Doyles of
 Ancient Ireland

About the Clan

Clan-Heraldry
for all Doyle Clan Members

The Clan Badge

The Clan Gathering

 Clan Gathering
Highlights 99

Where are they 
today

Sponsors

Saint Patrick

Traditional Celtic Dress

Irish Tartans

Doyle Tartan

Our Patron

Irish Chiefs

The Gift Shop

Doyle Heraldry

Doyle Coats of Arms

Personal Coat of Arms

The Order of St Patrick

Doyle History 
Pt1
Antiquity to the 1100's 

Doyle History 
Pt2
1100's  to the 1640's
Doyle History 
Pt3
1640's to the 1690's
Doyle History 
Pt4
1690's to the 1790's
Doyle History 
Pt5
1790's  to the 1850's
Doyle History 
Pt6
1850's  to the 1880's
Doyle History 
Pt7
 1880's to the1900's 
Doyle History 
Pt8
 the 1900's to 1916 
Doyle History 
Pt9
1916  to the 1940's 
Doyle History 
Pt10
1940's  to today 

Roll of Honour
American Civil War

Roll of Honour
1914 - 1918

Roll of Honour
1916 -1922

Roll of Honour
1939 -1945
Roll of Honour
Korea - Vietnam

Doyle Links

Irish Clan Links

Irish Links

Genealogy Links

Celtic Links

The Battle of 
Clontarf

The Normans Invade
Ireland
Cromwell Devastates
Ireland
The Jacobite War in
Ireland
The Battle of the Boyne

"Wild Geese"
Irish Soldiers in Exile

The Irish Viking 
Trail

Irish & Celtic
  Festivals

Doyle Web Rings

Joining The Clan

St Patrick's Cross Flag Irish Dog Breeds The Great Irish Warpipe Feedback Irish Soldiers
of
The British Army
Clan Bard Life Members Noble Society
of Celts
Doyles in
Argentina
No Irish Need Apply

 Last updated 3 December, 2011